Financial Mistakes Homeowners Make When Renting Out Their Spare Room

Renting out a spare room can be a fantastic way for homeowners to earn extra income and offset their mortgage costs. However, while the idea of having a renter sounds straightforward, many homeowners overlook the financial pitfalls that can arise.

Managing a rental space comes with its own set of responsibilities, and failing to account for these can lead to costly mistakes.

To help you navigate the process, let’s take a look at some of the common financial mistakes homeowners make when renting out their spare room and, more importantly, how to avoid them.

IMAGE: UNSPLASH

1. Not Setting The Right Rental Price

One of the most common mistakes homeowners make is pricing their spare room either too high or too low.

Charging too much can deter potential renters, leading to a prolonged vacancy, while setting the rent too low means you might not cover expenses or get fair compensation for the space.

How to Avoid It: Research the local rental market to understand the average price for similar rooms in your area. Take into account factors such as location, room size, access to amenities, and included utilities.

You can also use rental websites to get a sense of what others are charging. It’s important to strike a balance between being competitive and ensuring your rental income covers your costs.

2. Ignoring Tax Implications

The extra income from renting out a room is taxable, yet many homeowners don’t factor in the tax implications, leading to unpleasant surprises come tax season. Failing to report rental income or misunderstanding the deductions you can claim will result in penalties and additional taxes owed.

How to Avoid It: Familiarize yourself with tax rules concerning rental income. The IRS considers rental income taxable, but there are also deductions available, such as maintenance expenses, property insurance, and utilities.

Keep detailed records of all rental-related income and expenses to ensure you can accurately report your earnings and claim allowable deductions. Consulting with a tax professional can help you avoid any pitfalls and take full advantage of eligible tax breaks.

3. Overlooking Maintenance Costs

It’s easy to think of renting out a spare room as a source of passive income, but the truth is, there are ongoing costs associated with keeping your property in good condition.

Homeowners often overlook expenses such as wear and tear, repairs, and the upkeep of shared spaces, which can quickly add up.

How to Avoid It: Set aside a portion of your rental income for maintenance and repairs. Establish a routine for inspecting the property and addressing any small issues before they become major problems.

Consider creating a budget that includes regular maintenance tasks like cleaning common areas, replacing light bulbs, and servicing HVAC systems. Planning ahead will ensure you won’t be caught off guard by unexpected repair bills.

4. Not Screening Tenants Properly

Choosing the wrong tenant can be one of the costliest mistakes a homeowner can make. It can lead to unpaid rent, property damage, or even legal disputes. Rushing the tenant selection process or skipping background and credit checks can leave you vulnerable to financial loss.

How to Avoid It: Screen potential tenants thoroughly. This includes conducting credit checks, verifying income, and asking for references from previous landlords or roommates. It’s also wise to interview potential tenants to get a sense of their lifestyle and whether it will be a good fit.

Using a trusted platform like SpareRoom can help you with finding reliable roommates in NYC, Austin, Boston, LA, or anywhere else in the US.

5. Failing To Draft A Proper Rental Agreement

Some homeowners choose informal agreements, relying on verbal understandings or simple written notes. This can lead to confusion and disputes over responsibilities and payment terms. Without a legally binding agreement, it can be difficult to enforce your rules or pursue unpaid rent if things go awry.

How to Avoid It: Always use a written rental agreement that clearly outlines all the terms, including rent amount, payment due dates, security deposit, rules regarding common areas, and responsibilities for utilities. It should be signed by both parties and include details on how conflicts will be handled.

6. Underestimating Insurance Needs

Standard homeowner’s insurance may not cover liabilities associated with renting out a room. Many homeowners make the mistake of assuming their existing policy will suffice, only to find out later that they aren’t covered for damages caused by a tenant or if a renter is injured on the property.

How to Avoid It: Contact your insurance provider to discuss your options. Make sure you understand what is covered and what isn’t so that you can address any gaps in coverage. This step protects both you and your new roommate, offering peace of mind.

7. Not Factoring In Utility Costs

Including utilities in the rent can be a convenient option, but homeowners often forget to adjust the rental price if utility usage increases hugely. This can happen during extreme weather months when heating or cooling costs spike, leaving you paying more than you anticipated.

How to Avoid It: If you decide to include utilities in the rent, monitor the average monthly costs. You could set a cap on utility usage, with roommates responsible for any excess amount, or agree to split evenly.

8. Skipping Regular Inspections

Once you have a roommate or tenant in place, it’s easy to overlook the importance of regular property inspections. Without checking in from time to time, small maintenance issues can go unnoticed and escalate into more costly problems.

How to Avoid It: Schedule regular inspections, preferably every three to six months, to ensure that the room you’re renting out is being well-cared for.

Use these inspections as an opportunity to address any concerns your roommate might have and to keep an eye out for potential issues that need attention.

9. Overlooking Legal Requirements

Mistakes such as failing to return a security deposit on time, not following eviction procedures correctly, or neglecting safety requirements (like smoke detectors) can result in bigger problems down the line.

How to Avoid It: Research local renting laws and understand your rights and responsibilities as a homeowner or landlord. Consulting with a real estate attorney can help ensure compliance with local regulations and prevent legal headaches.

10. Using Personal Accounts For Rental Finances

Mixing personal and rental finances can complicate your financial records and tax reporting. It makes it harder to track rental income and expenses, leading to potential mistakes when filing taxes.

How to Avoid It: Set up a separate bank account for rental transactions. This simplifies financial tracking and makes it easier to keep accurate records for tax purposes.

Using a separate account ensures that rental income and expenses are clearly documented, minimizing the risk of errors when you’re preparing to pay tax.

Room For Rent – Conclusion

Renting out a spare room is a great way to generate extra income, but it’s crucial to be aware of potential financial mistakes that can arise.

By taking the time to set the right rental price, understanding tax implications, budgeting for maintenance, and properly screening roommates, you can avoid many common pitfalls. Using a platform like SpareRoom to find reliable roommates can also make the process smoother and more successful.