Is AI Killing Creativity In Advertising?

Artificial intelligence has become essential in modern advertising. According to industry estimates, AI-powered content creation can cut production costs by up to 65–70%. It also boosts click-through rates by 20–70%, offering marketers a faster and more data-driven way to engage consumers.

Many brands now rely on AI for media planning, ad personalization, and campaign optimization. While the gains in speed and scale are evident, the emotional depth of these campaigns is often called into question.

IMAGE: UNSPLASH

At Cannes Lions 2025, the global advertising industry’s most prestigious awards event, judges made a clear statement. AI-generated entries were outperformed by campaigns led by human creatives.

The Grand Prix winners included Telstra’s stop-motion animation campaign and Dove’s ‘Real Beauty’ ads, which leaned heavily on authentic storytelling and real-life emotion. These ads struck a chord with audiences because they told genuine human stories, something current AI systems still struggle to achieve.

The jury emphasized that while AI is a useful tool, it is not a substitute for human insight. Campaigns that relied too much on AI were criticized for being visually perfect but emotionally flat. This reinforces the idea that creativity must go beyond algorithmic logic.

Creatives Face Automation Anxiety

The growing use of AI in ad agencies has also sparked job insecurity. Junior designers, copywriters, and mid-level art directors are particularly at risk of being replaced or sidelined. Agencies have started restructuring teams to include fewer creatives and more data scientists and prompt engineers.

A recent industry survey revealed that 62% of creative professionals believe AI poses a threat to the uniqueness of their work. Some fear the industry will prioritize speed and cost savings over bold, imaginative ideas.

Interestingly, a meta-analysis conducted in early 2025 found that creatives working alongside AI tools outperformed those working alone. However, the diversity of ideas dropped, suggesting that AI tends to push creators toward safer, more generic content. This trend can stifle risk-taking and originality.

Ethical And Legal Concerns Rising

As AI becomes more integrated into the creative process, legal and ethical questions are coming to the forefront. Some brands now require agencies to disclose the use of AI-generated elements in campaigns.

This is partly to maintain transparency and partly to manage the risks of plagiarism, bias, or misinformation that AI content can unintentionally introduce.

AI systems also raise compliance concerns, particularly in regulated sectors like healthcare, finance, and politics. Advertisers are working to establish clear boundaries on how and when AI should be utilized, and industry watchdogs are closely monitoring the developments.

Conclusion: Amplify, Don’t Replace

AI is undoubtedly reshaping advertising, reducing costs, increasing output, and enabling precision targeting. However, it cannot fully replace human creativity, intuition, and emotional nuance. The future of advertising likely lies in a hybrid model where humans guide AI tools to produce more thoughtful and impactful campaigns.

AI should not take over creativity; it should be used as a tool to amplify human expression, not dilute it.